At The Backer Law Firm,
We’ve Got Your Back.

What if security cameras were not working during an attack?

An attack in a commercial parking lot can cause injuries and lasting fear. Learning that the security cameras were broken may add to that distress and raise concerns about the property’s safety.

If you suffered harm during such an incident, missing footage does not necessarily defeat your claim. Reviewing the property’s security practices can clarify who had notice and which evidence remains.

Here are possible outcomes that may emerge from that review and affect the investigation or your claim.

The business may face liability

In Missouri, a business generally has no duty to guard against a third party’s harmful act unless it knew or had reason to know that the conduct was occurring or reasonably likely in that area. It must also have had enough time to prevent the injury. Earlier incidents, reports or warnings may show that the business knew about a recurring danger and had a duty to respond.

Other proof may replace video

Without footage, police may have difficulty identifying or tracking the attacker. Yet witness accounts, incident reports, inspection records and internal messages could support your civil case. These materials might reveal when the system failed, who knew and why the business delayed repairs.

Fault may reduce compensation

Missouri follows a pure comparative-fault system in negligence cases. This means a court may reduce compensation based on the injured person’s share of responsibility instead of barring recovery entirely. For example, disregarding a posted safety warning could reduce compensation if that conduct contributed to the harm. Walking alone, however, should not establish fault by itself.

Why timely action matters

A negligent security claim often depends on the full circumstances, not the camera failure alone. Its strength may turn on how the business responded to an apparent danger before the attacker caused harm.

Delays can make that history harder to reconstruct. Legal guidance may help preserve evidence, assess recoverable losses and file the case within the applicable deadline.

FindLaw Network